Law Story: You can’t make this stuff up!

By | January 13, 2014

title insurance New YorkNo one ever said being an attorney was easy but this story about a matrimonial attorney in the UK being sued by a client is a doozy!

Of course the fact is that being an attorney, regardless of specialization, has its ups and downs.

In the first place lawyers often have to put up with the jokes directed at their profession. For instance,

What’s the difference between a good lawyer and a bad lawyer?

A bad lawyer can let a case drag out for several years. A good lawyer can make it last even longer.

That seems unfair!

And then there’s dealing with the disgruntled clients when a case may not go their way.

But this one is truly a head-scratcher!

Woman claims lawyers should have told her divorce would end her marriage

A British woman attempted to sue her former lawyers for professional negligence, claiming that, alongside a number of other allegations, they failed to advise that finalising divorce proceedings would inevitably cause her marriage to end.

The curious case – made against two solicitor firms – had already been rejected by the court, but was revealed in the transcript of a later appeal by the claimant against the dismissal of other aspects of her case.

Jane Mulcahy had argued that the lawyers should have made it clear that a divorce would cause her marriage to be terminated – something which she apparently wanted to avoid.

The lawyers failed to regard her Roman Catholic faith and should have recommended judicial separation – a step down from full divorce – as an alternative course of action, she said.

The allegation was revealed in a subsequent appeal court judgment last month, in which Lord Justice Briggs said: “The most striking of Mrs Mulcahy’s many allegations of negligence against her solicitors was that, having regard to her Roman Catholic faith, Mrs Boots had failed to give her the advice which was requisite in view of her firmly held belief in the sanctity of marriage…

“…either in terms of the alternative of judicial separation, or about the impossibility of pursuing divorce proceedings to a clean break settlement, without thereby inevitably bringing about the final termination of her marriage, which she wished to avoid.”

The appeal was also dismissed. (Source)

This would be like suing a company because it didn’t warn you that eating sixteen of its pizzas would likely cause you to gain weight. Not that somebody wouldn’t try!


If you have questions about any aspect of title insurance please contact us!

Also remember that you have the right to choose your title insurance provider and that non-title insurance fees can vary substantially from firm to firm! 

If you would like to have Hallmark Abstract Service provide you with a sample title bill for an upcoming transaction (we charge our cost for the non-title insurance premium fees) please give us a call at 516.741.4723 or send us an email at

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.